Register  ▪  Login  ▪  Current Issue  ▪  Contact Us  ▪  Advertise
search
Skip Navigation Links
Resources
Inspiration
Competitions
Directory
Education
DesignCasts
Print Blogs
Shop
About Us
Subscribe
Job List
 
About the Author
Steven Heller is the cofounder and the cochair of the MFA Designer as Author program at the School of Visual Arts. He writes the Visuals column for the New York Times Book Review and the Graphic Content blog for T-Style; is editor of AIGA Voice; and is a contributor to Design Observer.  He is the author, coauthor, and/or editor of more than 120 books on design and popular culture, including the forthcoming New Ornamental Type (Thames and Hudson). More information can be found at Heller's homepage.
 
See all Daily Heller posts here.   

Symbolic Idiocy

by Steven Heller
Share/Save/Bookmark

 
Hitler killed millions and enslaved many more. For all their political missteps and deceits, Presidents Lyndon B. Johnson, Richard M. Nixon, Jimmy Carter, Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush should not be equated with Hitler. For opponents to smear a Hitler mustache on any of them trivializes the valid criticism and satire that each deserves. Currently, owing to the heated health care debates, President Obama has also been tarred with this despicable Nazi brand.
 
To show the utter stupidity of this kind of visual commentary, I offer various iterations, yet this is only a small sampling of what's out there. Most are anonymous, but the first "known" Hitler image was in a 1968 issue of The East Village Other (below) of LBJ as Der Führer. A few years later, Ralph Steadman comically portrayed Richard Nixon in a characteristically Hitlerian pose (below, second). Nixon's chiefs of staff--Bob Haldeman and John Ehrlichman--were often made out to be Nazi henchmen by cartoonists. George Bush was the president most commonly affixed with the Hitler mustache, but even almost-president Hillary Clinton has had her share. And now President Obama is the object of this ignorant symbolic opportunism. Watch Congressman Barney Frank's brilliant response here
 
Hitler remains one of the world's top villains. To reduce his infamous visage to a ludicrous scold is injustice to all. Remember. Symbols are powerful things: don't waste them or wear them out.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Reader Comments
Login to add a comment. Not a registered user? Register Now!
Owing to some unexplained technical glitch the comments posted to this thread have disappeared. If you'd like to repost, please do. Of course, this is disturbing, and we are doing everything we can to rectify. - editors
By Steven Heller  August 26, 2009 
Reprehensible as the rising use of Hitler imagery is, one must examine its effect beyond the dilution, (and thus the acceptablity), of this visual environment. For this we can point a finger not only at those who lack the imagination to express themselves without reverting to monstrous cliché, but to commercial interests as well, viz. the summer "Germany" issue of Heeb magazine. The irony here is that those who use Nazi imagery to make a statement do so in exactly the same way the Nazis did: Making a statement to which there is no possibility for reply - only the possibility for repetition. Who's the Nazi now?
By mkace  August 23, 2009 
master class
Facebook  Flickr StumbleUpon Twitter
Share  Share this page with your friends.
Image of the Day

Image of the Day February 8, 2012 
Gig poster for Thurston Moore at Maxwell's, Hoboken. Design by Morning Breath.

Most Recent Articles
Why Designers Still Can't Think
Power by Design
Gchatting with Jennifer Daniel
An Anatomy of Uncriticism
Print's February 2012 Issue
Most Popular

Carry Hope

13 designers create a custom tote bag for their favorite charity. Featuring the work of: Atelier Télescopique, Büro Destruct, Christoph Niemann, Deanne Cheuk, Ed Fella, Geoff McFetridge, Hort, James Joyce, Laurent Fetis, Rick Valicenti, Si Scott, Spin, and Sawdust. Order one today!
 
 
Check Out Past Issues

Subscribe to Print and get all 6 issues for just $40

In This Issue:
The Power Issue, in which we examine the true influence of design and the designer. On the cover: We asked Mirko Ilić to reinterpret one of the classic graphics created by Philippe Vermès during the 1968 French protests. To see the original, click here. To purchase print or digital copies of current or past issues of Print, click here.
 
 
 
 
June 2011 April 2011February 2011
Skip Navigation Links
Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Site Map
Job List
Copyright © 2012 by F+W Media.