Register today for the free course “5 Skills Every Design Needs to Know.”
In 1948 the designer, typographer and illustrator (and sometime curmudgeon) Thomas Maitland Cleland (1880–1964) gave a talk at the Newberry Library in Chicago to the Society of Typographic Arts on the nature of “‘Progress’ in the Graphic Arts.” His signature tone was slightly sarcastic, heavily cautionary and always critical. Oh yes, and endearingly entertaining unless you were on the stinging side of his barbs. In 1950 the talk was “printed in privacy” by The Overbrook Press (Stamford, Connecticut). You get an inkling from where he was headed with his explanation of the quirky title page: “The title page of this edition is designed in ‘dynamic functionalism’—the function in this case being to call attention to the designer’s creative originality and show that even a slave of ‘outworn tradition’ may progress.” I reproduce the entire document below as an example of design criticism before the age of design criticism.