When Green Equaled Racist

Ruth Benedict was a visionary American anthropologist and poet whose theories had a profound influence on cultural anthropology in the area of culture and personality. A student of Franz Boaz, her mark on anthropology was rooted in a strong humanistic background that she employed to thwart racism. Her first book was Patterns of Culture (1934); she demonstrates in her research of distant culutures “how small a portion of the possible range of human behavior is incorporated into any one culture; she argues that it is the ‘personality,’ the particular complex of traits and attitudes, of a culture that defines the individuals within it as successes, misfits, or outcasts.” With the publication of Race: Science and Politics (1940) she refuted racist theory proving that the human race is one race.

In 1947 Ruth Benedict and her colleague in the Columbia University anthropology department, Gene Weltfish’s In Henry’s Backyard: The Races of Mankind was published to mixed reviews. It was a collaboration with the legendary animation studio UPA, famous for its Gerald McBoing Boing and Mr. Magoo cartoons, which had done a brilliant cartoon titled The Brotherhood of Man.

races of man

The Races of Mankind, which she wrote with Gene Weltfish, was a small pamphlet that sold millions of copies, was translated into the UPA cartoon, and wrote Margaret Mead in Benedict’s 1948 obituary “has proved perhaps the most important single translation into genuine popular education of the many years of careful research on race differences to which anthropologists have made a major contribution.” Based on the drawings from animated cartoon, Dr. Weltfish and Violet Edwards under Dr. Benedict’s direction, created a document that argued against the power of the “green devils,” racists by any other name.

The New York Times Book Review criticized the art but also the premise of racial equality: “until much more is known about human genetics it will hardly be possible to lay down the law on heredity vs. environment in measuring racial capability.” Read more in this insightful essay from Tales for Little Rebels: A Collection of Radical Children’s Literature edited by Julia L. Mickenberg and Philip Nel.

The book is part of a genre, that includes Robert Osborn‘s War Is No Damn Good, which seeks to simplify complex ideas without reducing them to pablum. In a way, these are the precursors of today’s data visualizations and information graphics.

Below are excerpted spreads from Henry’s Backyard where Henry awakens into the grip of racism until his epiphany . . .

“Oh,” said Henry, “I’m beginning to get it . . . we’re not born haters. Our Green Devils of prejudice and fear grow inside us . . . because we are worried and afraid.”

races of man 1 races of man 2 races of man 3 races of man 13 races of man 11 races of man 10 races of man 9 races of man 8 races of man 7 races of man 6 races of man 5 races of man 4 races of man 12 races of man 14 races of man 15 races of man 16

One thought on “When Green Equaled Racist

  1. gaiagenesis

    This book was hugely impactful to me when I was read it as a child in the ’60s. I kept it and read it to my own child in the ’90s. Now I work in human rights for the U.S. State Department and am thinking of mirroring some of the cartoon style in a series of infographics I am producing to counter global trafficking in persons. I believe the style universally appealing and transcends cultural, national barriers.