Paul Krassner’s Fake News and the Power of Positive Hoaxing

“The truth is vastly overrated.” That’s how I began my feature for the AIGA Journal of Graphic Design’s “Truth” issue back in the year 2000. And now post-truth, fake news and other euphemisms for lies have become accepted standard operating procedure in our current cultural and political climate. But hey, don’t blame me. On the contrary, my piece was in praise of the hoaxes perpetrated by The Realist, a pioneering publication of “freethought criticism and satire.” Honestly.

Scott Gandell: Bogus News Frustration

Scott Gandell: Bogus News Frustration

Way back in the late 1950s, when our country was still reeling from McCarthyism, stand-up comedian Paul Krassner—stage name: Paul Maul; ouch!—decided to publish and edit The Realist as an alternative and an antidote to the frauds and hypocrisies of our politics and culture. Both he and his magazine soon became a vital inspiration for, influence on, and participant in the countercultural revolution of the 1960s.

The Realist‘s distribution dwindled and eventually disappeared after its ‘sixties heyday, but its satiric spirit is still alive and thriving. When the four Charlie Hebdo cartoonists were murdered in Paris, I wrote a Print essay—available here—in which I directly linked that courageous publication with The Realist’s “often scathingly vulgar and uncompromisingly offensive… and hey, hilariously funny” texts and ‘toons. Time and other publications promptly echoed my analogy.

Scott Gandell: Bat Boy, All Grown Up

Scott Gandell: Bat Boy, All Grown Up

And in our own country Krassner’s satiric sensibility can be spotted online with Funny or Die and The Onion. It’s also been spreading on TV over the years via The Daily Show and its progeny, including Steven Colbert, who coined the pre-“post-truth” term “truthiness,” and the belligerently brilliant Lewis Black. When asked in an interview what led him to choose social and political satire the focus of his comedy Black responded, “Paul Krassner wrote a magazine called The Realist which was a really extraordinary, unbelievable satire for its era. Reading really good satire can be like taking a drug. It rearranges the way you look at things.”

Among the countless others for whom Krassner has been an important inspiration, the strangest may have been Andrew Breitbart, despite their diametrically opposite worldviews. Breitbart is the founder of Breitbart News, notorious for using fake news sites to source their dishonest and deceptive “journalism.” When Krassner interviewed Breitbart for Playboy in 2011, he said he admired Krassner’s “trailblazing and causing mischief and mirth and effecting the type of political and social change you were attempting.”

And now the Chairman of Breitbart Media is about to become the new President’s chief strategist. So, despite a somewhat tenuous relationship to design, it appears timely to revisit that AIGA Journal profile I wrote, “Here Lies Paul Krassner.” Among several other stories, I discuss the time the FBI anonymously distributed leaflets in black neighborhoods that called for the “elimination” of Krassner and other Jews. The headline was “Lampshades!” repeated four times. Fortunately, he’s still with us at age 84. But so’s the FBI: two weeks prior to last month’s Presidential election the FBI Director’s public, vaguely worded, announcement of a tenuously-related email investigation did manage to shoot down some potential votes for candidate Clinton. Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose.

Scott Gandell: Bookface.

Scott Gandell: Bookface.

One more thing. Back in 2012, I published a Print interview with Krassner—which you can read here—that I illustrated with a number of Realist cartoons. Shortly after that, Fantagraphics Books offered him a deal to publish a volume of Realist cartoons. Coincidence or crackpot speculation? You be the judge.

In either event, The Realist Cartoons was released a few days ago, and it’s quite impressive. Its nearly 300 generously-sized pages are rich with well over 800 clever, trenchant, irreverent social and political critique. It also provides a unique pictorial chronicle of a turbulent, transformative era. You’ll find artwork by the likes of Art Spiegelman—who once referred to The Realist as grad school for Mad readers—Robert Crumb, Wallace Wood, Stan Mack, Nicole Hollander, and Terry Gilliam. You’ll find a sampling below. And Scott Gandell—whose portrait of Krassner tops that interview—is back for his graphic take on the fake news phenomenon, created exclusively for this Print feature.

Richard Guindon, 1966

Richard Guindon, 1966

Here Lies Paul Krassner

~ Michael Dooley, AIGA Journal, 2000

The truth is vastly overrated.

Oh sure, it’s easy to condemn news programs, advertisers, and websites for falsifying information. But we should also consider the upside of lying. In essence, a hoax is a lie. Skillfully executed, it can serve to subvert the authority of the mass media with progressive results.

During last year’s anti-World Trade Organization protests, activists wrapped a four-page bogus newspaper section around several thousand copies of the Seattle Post-Intelligencer prior to sales. The parody contained fabricated news items mocking corporate malfeasance. Readers were tricked, if only for a moment, into mistaking anti-establishment propaganda for official propaganda. This “culture jamming” is part of a tradition of guerrilla communication that includes Russian samizdat, John Heartfield’s photomontages, and Situationist détournement. And let’s not forget the mischief made by Paul Krassner.

J.C. Suares, 1966

J.C. Suares, 1966

Over the past half-century, Krassner has been personally responsible for some of the cleverest put-ons ever foisted upon an unsuspecting audience. He is founder and editor of The Realist, a magazine once described by the Library Journal as the best satirical publication in America. People magazine called Krassner the father of the underground press—but he demanded a blood test.

In 1958, during the repressive Eisenhower era, Krassner’s read Esquire‘s “America Needs a Punch” by Malcolm Muggeridge, the British humor magazine’s former editor. Taking the article as a personal directive, the 26-year-old Krassner debuted his 35-cent, 32-page pulp paper monthly, with a base of 600 subscribers and himself as the only staff member. The Realist was a confluence of factors: Krassner’s knowledge of the tradition of alternative journalism from Ben Franklin’s and Tom Paine’s broadsides to I. F. Stone’s Weekly; his experience as a Mad writer and stand-up raconteur; and his desire to share the delight he felt as a child when he realized he’d been fooled into believing radio performers Jack Benny and Fred Allen were feuding in real life.

Art Spiegelman, 1969 and Richard Guindon, 1967

Art Spiegelman, 1969 and Richard Guindon, 1967

From the outset, The Realist was a brave magazine, printing material no other publication would touch. It dealt with free speech, abortion rights, women’s equality, and psychedelics long before these topics surfaced in the mainstream media. Through articles and interviews it included countercultural icons such as authors Norman Mailer, Joseph Heller, Terry Southern, Ken Kesey, and Kurt Vonnegut, as well as comedians Woody Allen, Dick Gregory, Mort Sahl, and Lenny Bruce.

Krassner financed The Realist through his freelance income, mostly as a writer and performer. Uncompromisingly independent, he never accepted ads or conducted marketing surveys, on the grounds that he might be influenced about what he prints. The only common denominator he saw among the magazine’s audience is “an irreverence for all the pious bullshit that surrounds us.” The Realist was originally subtitled “An Angry Young Magazine,” but over the years it’s used many tag lines, including “The Truth Is Silly Putty.”

Ed Fisher, 1964

Ed Fisher, 1964

The Realist‘s first foray into media flimflam was the infamous TV hoax of 1960. At the time television fare was purposefully bland, with hypersensitive programmers living in fear of alienating their market. After a Southerner saw what he thought was a Negro man kissing a white woman on TV, he wrote a letter threatening never to buy the sponsor’s product again. So the sponsor flew an account executive to the man’s home to prove that, due to faulty transmission at the local station, the leading man only appeared black. “In truth,” Krassner noted, “like so many leading men, he was colorless.”

To skewer this paranoid mindset, Krassner selected a particularly innocuous, inane NBC game show, Masquerade Party, and told readers to send indignant letters to the network, sponsors and ad agencies, claiming to take offense at some unspecified incident on a particular broadcast date. The station received more than a hundred such “complaints.” The sponsors were infuriated. The network sent letters of apology. The producers phoned people individually to assure each of them that he or she was the only one who had complained. All the while, no one had a clue as to what they were reacting to. Even more remarkable is that the thousands of Realist readers all kept the prank a secret from NBC.

Howard Shoemaker, 1961

Howard Shoemaker, 1961

In 1971 Krassner “reported” the first waterbed fatality, a fictional account of a man who was electrocuted when his TV with frayed electrical wires fell into a puddle made by a waterbed punctured by his cat’s claws. The item was picked up by the San Francisco Examiner and KCBS news, and at a furniture manufacturers’ convention a resolution was passed calling for higher safety standards in the manufacture of waterbeds. Krassner is proud of what he considers an act of “preventive journalism.”

Krassner never draws the line between truth and satire. “I don’t want to take away from the reader the pleasure of discerning it for themselves,” he says. In 1966, when The Realist reprinted an actual item from the well-respected Journal of the American Medical Association that dealt with drinking glasses, tennis balls, and other foreign bodies found in patients’ rectums, he was accused of having a perverted mind. One subscriber wrote, “I found the article thoroughly repellent. I trust you know what you can do with your magazine.”

B. Kliban, 1966 and James "JAF" Frankfort, 1961

B. Kliban, 1966 and James “JAF” Frankfort, 1961

The Realist published Lenny Bruce’s obituary in 1964, when the comedian was still alive. Krassner, who had edited Bruce’s autobiography, How to Talk Dirty and Influence People, had begun to write about the literal and figurative trials of his friend, whose views on religion and obscenity made him the target of government prosecution. At one point, he realized that Bruce, who was being denied his livelihood, might as well be dead. After it ran, Krassner received several inquiries from the media, wanting to know the meaning of this obit. The meaning became starkly evident two years later when Bruce—after enduring continued, relentless harassment and persecution—died from an overdose of morphine.

Among Krassner’s other satirical prophecies was his 1976 “Sneak Preview of Richard Nixon’s Memoirs,” published in Chic, in which Nixon insisted that Watergate was a setup to get rid of him as President. About a decade later, Tricky Dick made that exact claim on a network television interview.

Richard Guindon, 1970

Richard Guindon, 1970

Krassner’s coining of the term “Yippie” on New Year’s Eve of 1967 can be considered a massively successful hoax inasmuch as he created a group—oxymoronically, an anarchist organization—simply by defining it. He wanted a word to describe what he saw as “the organic coalition of psychedelic dropouts and political activists” that had performed an exorcism of the Pentagon and engaged in other absurd theatrics. He settled on “Yippie!” when he realized it would also function as an effective rallying cry. He then decided YIP should stand for Youth International Party, with the dual meaning of “party.” This instant myth helped draw radicalized hippies to Chicago the following year to demonstrate at the Democratic National Convention. The media became involuntary recruitment co-conspirators, providing millions of dollars’ worth of free publicity as they reported on Yippie events such as running a pig for President.

Charles B. Slackman, 1962

Charles B. Slackman, 1962

Krassner’s most inflammatory hoax was the cover story of the May 1967 issue, “The Parts that Were Left Out of the Kennedy Book.” The book in question was The Death of a President, written by the historian William Manchester with the authorization of the Kennedy family. The public’s curiosity had been ignited by news that Jacqueline Kennedy was demanding portions of the manuscript she felt offensive be deleted. Failing to obtain the missing material, Krassner, in his role of investigative satirist, decided to author it himself.

Like Jonathan Swift, with his “Modest Proposal” that eating Irish babies was a solution to famine and overpopulation, Krassner attempted to make the excerpts as convincing as possible. He imitated Manchester’s style and improvised on information that was a matter of record, such as that Jackie had told the writer Gore Vidal she’d witnessed Lyndon Johnson leaning over John Kennedy’s casket, chuckling. In Krassner’s version, she watches him moving rhythmically while crouched over the corpse. “And then I realized—there is only one way to say this—he was literally fucking my husband in the throat. In the bullet wound in the front of his throat.”

Krassner, who believes the ultimate target of satire should be its audience, included an editor’s note requesting readers include their zip code when canceling their subscriptions. Those who opened the magazine eager for sensationalistic revelations found themselves shocked to have their expectations met in the extreme. Others—who complacently accepted daily reports of the presidentially sanctioned napalming of Vietnamese villages—found themselves revolted by Johnson’s “neck-rophilia.” Cancellations poured in, with subscribers dutifully including their zip codes.

Richard Guindon, 1969

Richard Guindon, 1969

There was no official White House reaction; any denial would, in effect, be a concession that the incident was credible. As Krassner pointed out in a follow-up report, one of Johnson’s favorite jokes is about a popular Texas sheriff running for reelection whose opponents decide to spread a rumor that he fucks pigs: “We know he doesn’t, but let’s make the son of a bitch deny it.” However, news of the story had become so widespread that UPI correspondent Merriman Smith felt compelled to make a statement. In a ludicrously contorted attempt to discredit the story yet remain within the bounds of propriety, he wrote, “It is filth attributed to someone of national stature supposedly describing something Johnson allegedly did. The incident, of course, never took place.”

The article was intended as a metaphorical truth about LBJ’s crudity and lust for power. But there were many who accepted it as fact, including an ACLU lawyer, a Peabody Award-winning newsman, and people in high levels of the intelligence community who were in a position to know that such activities occur. Daniel Ellsberg believed it, and he would eventually go on to release the Pentagon Papers.

Richard Guindon, 1968

Richard Guindon, 1968

Krassner never topped that notorious stunt, although his 1975 Crawdaddy article, “A Friendly Conversation with Patty Hearst,” earned him a visit from FBI agents. They were looking for the fugitive newspaper heiress, even though he had her state that the FBI was partly responsible for her kidnapping.

Krassner’s toying with the FBI was a mild form of poetic retaliation for the Bureau’s own “hoaxes” against him. Their smear campaign included a poison-pen letter to the editor of Life magazine in 1968 after it had published a favorable profile of Krassner. Written by an agent under a false name, it accused Krassner of being “the cuckoo editor of an unimportant, smutty little rag” and “a raving, unconfined nut.” Although Life didn’t print the letter, it did publish one that read, “Regarding your article on that filthy-mouthed, dope-taking, pinko-anarchist, pope-baiting yippie-lover: cancel my subscription immediately!” Krassner had written it himself.

The following year, the FBI’s character assassination took a more literal turn when it produced and distributed a “Wanted” poster in black neighborhoods. Photos of Krassner and other political leftists—fellow Yippies Abbie Hoffman and Jerry Rubin and SDS leader Mark Rudd—were set inside a swastika. Accompanying text declared that “the only solution to Negro problems in America” was “the elimination of the Jews.”

Sam Gross, 2000 and Skip Williamson, 1967

Sam Gross, 2000 and Skip Williamson, 1967

The FBI was wise to consider Krassner a threat to the established order. Through his insightful, incisive iconoclasm, he has proven to be, as Joseph Heller observed, “a formidable bulwark against pollution by cant and hypocrisy.” He’s also demonstrated the enormous power and potential of alternative media.

The Realist‘s circulation peaked at 100,000 in the late 1960s. It was discontinued in 1974, when Krassner experienced a period of burnout, and started again in 1985 during the Reagan administration. It’s now a 12-page quarterly newsletter distributed to a a few thousand readers. After five collections of his work and an autobiography, Confessions of a Raving, Unconfined Nut, he’s announced this winter’s issue will be The Realist‘s last. [note to Print readers: it was.] At 68, he’s decided to concentrate on novels, which he finds challenging, even though he’s been making up material all his life. “But that was journalism,” he says.

Sam Gross, 1967

Sam Gross, 1967

To a large extent, Krassner has achieved his original goal: “To put myself out of business by helping to liberate communication by example.” As he predicted in 1962, controversy has become a commodity, and much of what used to appear in The Realist can now be found in mainstream outlets. The whereabouts of the presidential penis receives regular media scrutiny. [note: I wrote this article during Bill Clinton’s presidency.] Websites maintain lists of objects recovered from rectums. And countless internet users were recently deceived into believing a Chicago Tribune writer’s column advising “wear sunscreen” was actually an MIT commencement address by past Realist contributor Kurt Vonnegut. Krassner claimed he was the perpetrator of this cyberhoax, but even if he wasn’t, he deserves credit.

Because The Realist is an extension of Krassner’s unique personality, once it’s gone there will never be another publication remotely like it. He’s always considered his magazine to be art rather than commerce, and “as art, it can’t be imitated.” Certainly through, his hoaxes Krassner has amply fulfilled Picasso’s definition of art as “the lie that makes people see the truth.”

Terry Gilliam, 1965

Terry Gilliam, 1965

Dan O'Neill, 1974

Dan O’Neill, 1974


rda_callentrieseb

COMMENT